New Delhi [India]: India's rollout of E20 petrol has sparked widespread debate, with social media claims suggesting that insurance companies may reject claims if vehicles are damaged due to the higher ethanol blend.
The government has dismissed those claims as misleading, insurers have clarified that using E20 fuel does not invalidate motor insurance policies, and automakers have maintained that E20 is safe for compatible vehicles.
However, one important question remains unanswered: If E20 fuel eventually causes damage to a vehicle, who bears the cost—the insurer, the manufacturer or the vehicle owner?
Insurance remains valid, but coverage has limits
According to experts, there is an important distinction between keeping an insurance policy valid and having every type of damage covered under that policy.
"The fact that you are using E20 fuel does not invalidate your motor insurance policy. However, if damage arises due to gradual wear and tear or mechanical breakdown, those are standard exclusions under motor insurance," experts said.
In other words, a vehicle owner does not lose insurance coverage simply by using E20 petrol. But that does not automatically mean an insurer will pay for repairs if components deteriorate over time.
Why gradual damage is different
The confusion largely stems from the nature of motor insurance itself.
Standard comprehensive motor insurance is designed to cover sudden and accidental losses such as road accidents, theft, fire, floods or natural calamities. It generally does not cover damage resulting from normal ageing, wear and tear or mechanical failures.
For example, if over several years of use certain fuel-system components such as rubber hoses, seals, gaskets, fuel pumps or fuel lines deteriorate, insurers typically classify such failures as mechanical wear rather than accidental damage.
"These are wear and tear items. Irrespective of whether E20 is there or 100% petrol is there, they are considered damages due to wear and tear or mechanical breakdown, which are standard exclusions under the policy," experts explained.
Does zero depreciation cover help?
Many vehicle owners assume that a zero depreciation or bumper-to-bumper insurance policy offers complete protection.
Balisgol clarified that this is a misconception.
Zero depreciation is an add-on cover, not part of a standard comprehensive policy. Its primary purpose is to waive depreciation on replaced parts when the claim itself is admissible.
"If the accident is covered under the policy, then whatever depreciation is applicable on replaced parts gets waived off. Zero depreciation has no connection with E20 fuel," experts said.
In other words, if damage itself is excluded because it results from mechanical failure or gradual deterioration, a zero depreciation add-on does not change that.
What about consumables?
Components such as seals, hoses and gaskets are often treated as consumable or wear-and-tear items.
While some insurers offer separate consumables cover as an add-on, the insurance experts said these covers are not intended to compensate for gradual deterioration linked to regular usage.
As a result, even where consumables protection exists, claims arising from normal wear or mechanical breakdown generally remain outside the scope of motor insurance.
Could insurance products evolve?
As India expands ethanol blending and explores flex-fuel vehicles and other alternative fuels, insurance products may also need to evolve.
The experts believes insurers could eventually introduce broader protection plans covering mechanical failures alongside accidental damage.
"There are possibilities that insurance companies may come up with an all-risk cover where anything and everything happening to the vehicle, whether accidental or mechanical, is covered," experts said.
They added that many customers increasingly expect insurance to provide comprehensive protection rather than only accident-related coverage.
Automakers remain confident on E20
They also pointed out that vehicle manufacturers have publicly maintained that E20-compatible vehicles have been adequately tested.
Maruti Suzuki and Mahindra have both stated that E20 fuel does not adversely affect vehicles designed for the fuel blend, following necessary engineering changes and calibration.
As a consumer, you don't need to worry because OEMs are also taking responsibility to ensure there would not be such a situation, according to the experts.
They nevertheless advise vehicle owners to opt for add-on covers such as zero depreciation, engine protection, consumables cover, battery protection and roadside assistance to improve overall protection.
What consumers should know
At present, three key facts stand out:
Using E20 petrol does not automatically invalidate a motor insurance policy.
Using E20 petrol does not automatically void a manufacturer's warranty, according to government and industry statements.
There is currently no publicly established insurance framework specifically dealing with E20-related vehicle damage claims.
READ: Is it okay to burden people for Ethanol blending Experiment?
If E20 performs as manufacturers and the government expect, insurance disputes may never become a significant issue. But if questions emerge years later over gradual component failures, consumers may still face uncertainty over whether responsibility lies with insurers, manufacturers or vehicle owners.
For now, while insurance coverage remains intact, claims involving mechanical wear or gradual deterioration continue to be governed by long-standing exclusions that apply regardless of whether a vehicle runs on E20 or conventional petrol.
READ: ICAI renews recognition deal with CPA Australia
Follow NewsEdition.in on X (Twitter), LinkedIn for more stories on Politics, World, Business and more.
Ends.
Comments (0)
Be the first to comment!